Diversity and Religion.

I’m a bit worried about this post. I hope I’ve expressed myself properly.


I love religion. There, I’ve said it. I found it fascinating, for example, to visit here recently: http://gurunanakdarbar.org/?option=com_contact&view=contact&id=1&Itemid=49


and I really love this book, which I first encountered as a teenager. It was so interesting for me, a girl in a very devout Catholic world, to read the prayers of other traditions.



I love meeting other people and finding out about their religious traditions and beliefs. If I had the money, I’d love to do a degree in religious studies to learn more about Judaism, Islam, Buddhism and lots of other faiths. I also find it v interesting to talk to those who are agnostic or atheist – I think it is good to encounter other people’s opinions and world views, and to challenge our mutual prejudices. I think online and in the media we are constantly exposed to negative stereotypes about many things – and one of these is religion. Narrow minded, ignorant or violent bigots and terrorists claim to speak on behalf of Islam or Christianity or any number of other faiths, and I worry that people seem to accept these self-appointed spokespeople and their skewed take on religion as the final word. A religious perspective, in these terms, would seem to be in direct opposition to any commitment to diversity. Religion is linked to homophobia, misogyny and hatred. I worry that because of this, if I tell someone I am religious, all sorts of bad things will be associated with me. At best I will be seen as unthinking or plain stupid, at worst narrow minded and judgemental and hate-filled. But this, I would maintain, is a form of prejudice too.


I accept that many awful things have been done and are being done in the name of many things – one of which is religion – and there are genuine issues about religious morality and ethics which may seem at times to work against diversity. Diversity isn’t necessarily easy, as I said in a post before. But I’d like to say that’s not the whole story. I think religion and diversity are two words which can go together very well.


I am religious. Yesterday, 18th February 2015, was Ash Wednesday, the beginning of the Christian season of Lent. I am a Roman Catholic. My husband, who is a teacher, and my three youngest children, all teenagers, and my 87 year old dad, and I all went to Ash Wednesday mass in our local Catholic church. It was midday, and I didn’t expect there to be many people there. It was packed. Standing room only. I looked about and what I saw and heard really moved me. There were about 500 people of all ages, backgrounds and nationalities. It amazed me and made me want to write about it.


Yesterday, in church, what struck me was the sheer diversity of people there, firstly in terms of age. There were elderly people, but there were also middle aged workers on lunch break, younger people in their twenties, students from the university, teenagers, school children, toddlers and babies. There were LOTS of children. There were also people in my church from all sorts of educational and economic backgrounds who each have an equal place. There is an MP, but he worships along side a homeless man who wears a fancy dress native american head dress and a kilt and carries a set of bagpipes he cannot play. There are families of Irish travellers, there are nurses, lawyers, building labourers and cleaners, unemployed people, students, doctors and dentists, office workers and university lecturers and shop workers and clerical workers and teachers. There are fashionable and dowdy, fit and unfit, rich and poor. I love this.


The priest who led the service is our young Nigerian curate. He is fantastic, full of sincerity and love. At least a third of the people there were from other countries – yesterday there were lots of families from India, for example. I recognised some of the nurses – male and female- who had looked after my elderly mother when she was ill, and they came with their young children. There were people from Africa and the Caribbean, and the Philippines, and I know there were Polish, Romanians and French. I expect there were Portugese, Italian, German and Irish there too. I imagine a number of the people there were tourists on holiday, and we often have visitors from the United States.


We have a loop system for those with hearing problems in our church, and there are always a number of mobility scooters and walking frames in the aisles. One lovely elderly lady I see at mass regularly drives up to the front on her mobility scooter and promptly falls asleep through most of the service, then she wakes up, gives a beautiful smile and drives off again. A nurse from the Philippines who, after working for years in our local hospital, had a catastrophic stroke affecting her speech and mobility, comes to mass in her electronic wheelchair. I was struck yesterday by a young man with a dramatically stark metallic artificial leg who walked up with his little daughter to receive the ashes. People from the local L’Arche community of people with learning difficulties and their assistants regularly worship in our church. I know of at least two people with a diagnosis of dementia in our church and I am sure there are people with all sorts of hidden disabilities and terminal and chronic illnesses and health worries amongst the congregation – some I will know – some I will never know – but I know that the people there will be praying to God about them.


There is a notice board and post it notes at the back of the church for people to write prayers on. They are left on display so that all the rest of the people can read them and pray too. The subjects are very moving – young soldiers about to go to war zones, asylum seekers begging for refuge, people suffering from cancer, people feeling isolated and lonely, students sitting exams, people who have had miscarriages, or who need a job, or a home, or who are asking for forgiveness. There are thank you prayers too – for work, for love, for health. There are a million plots for a million novels, for adults and, I believe, for children. There is yellow food bank bin at the back of the church. There are envelopes to put money in for overseas aid. There is a collecting box for the St Vincent de Paul Society, which helps families with financial problems. In various parts of the church there are candle stands, and people rush to them after mass (and sometimes, distractingly, during it!). You hear the sound of the money falling in the box, and you look to see someone standing, a candle in their hand, praying. It is unselfconscious and beautiful and often very moving. This is part of contemporary children’s reality – not all children’s – but a sizeable amount.


I don’t want to airbrush this. I know there will be challenges in reconciling the concerns of a literature reflecting many aspects of diversity in our modern world, and reflecting truthfully the values of often very conservative religions, but I think that makes this challenge for writers all the more worthwhile. This is the world in which I grew up and in which I see other children growing up and I don’t have the impression that there are many – if any – mainstream children’s novels being published today which show a positive view of a contemporary child praying within a religious tradition. I’d love to know if there are – so please let me know any recommendations.


I know that on my own journey to publication I have been told by different people to avoid writing books with religious child characters as they would be unlikely to be taken on by current mainstream UK publishers.  I wonder if this is true – and if it is, what that says about commitment to true diversity. I’d really like to see more children’s novels published – and write some of them myself – that are set in today’s world and have a positive view of religion – not to try to make non- religious children religious – but in the interest both of creating a world another group of underrepresented children can see themselves in, and in introducing it to others who do not know it.  I think, in this world of tensions and misunderstanding and intolerance, that it could be a real way to increase empathy and respect and understanding between those children who experience life as members of a religion, many of whom are from racial minorities, and those who don’t.


7 thoughts on “Diversity and Religion.

  1. Clare February 20, 2015 at 8:36 am Reply

    I too live in a small community in which we are bringing up our children to have religion, if not faith, then at least a religious cultural identity, and I struggle to see this represented in children’s literature. I always thought it was perhaps because there were too few of us that it wasn’t viewed as being relevant. I do see religion and cultural difference portrayed very much as the ‘other’, the immigrant, the refugee etc in chlidren’s books and although there is nothing wrong with this, there is very limited portrayal of what you call a “contemporary child praying within a religious tradition”. In fact, also I have struggled to find things such as Bible stories retold in a manner in which is acceptable to a modern child – anything to do with traditional religion almost seems packaged up in a politically correct curriculum way, rather than as a read for pleasure title. eg. stories such as David and Goliath – which could be reinterpreted/narrated in a great modern way. Your point also in that people seem scared to make religion a ‘thing’ in case it becomes the fearful ‘thing’, the scary other, which it seems to have become in our news narrative nowadays. You’re right again, in that good religion can embrace diversity and, particularly community. Interesting blog – thanks.

  2. includedbygrace February 20, 2015 at 9:25 am Reply

    Really well written Anne. You make really good points, especially that at its best and most real, church can be the most diverse and inclusive place. I would love to see faith and he cultures it supports being represented in children’s literature, just as part of the characters lives. Too many stories use religion as the reason a character rebelled, or murdered or was abused. While this can be the case, it is still relatively rare compared to all the good in religios life.

  3. bridgeanneartandwriting February 20, 2015 at 9:29 am Reply

    Thank you both so much.

  4. Virginia Moffatt (@aroomofmyown1) February 20, 2015 at 9:46 am Reply

    I think you definitely should Anne. And if people are wary point out Marilynne Robinson as a Pulitzer Prize winning, Orange Prize winning novelist whose Gilead series completely concentrates on what it means to lead lives of faith. Also Barbara Kingsolver in Flight Behaviour has a really interesting Baptist church with a lovely minister as critical to the story. What’s good enough for grown ups should be good enough for kids too!

  5. bridgeanneartandwriting February 20, 2015 at 9:58 am Reply

    Thanks Virginia!

  6. Susie Day February 20, 2015 at 12:40 pm Reply

    Great post, Anne. Since you’re talking about diversity and inclusion, I have to flag up your use of the phrase ‘red indian head dress’; the term ‘red indian’ is widely considered offensive and ‘native american’ is preferred (although native american culture as represented by the west is usually completely inaccurate, so he’s probably not wearing anything particularly connected to it anyway). I wouldn’t want that to distract from your core message; I’m an atheist (though I was raised Anglican), but I absolutely value the community that a religious faith can provide, and I too worry about the misrepresentation by those who appropriate faith to justify bigotry and terror. I’d recommend RJ Anderson’s MG faerie series, beginning with Knife, for kidlit that incorporates Christianity in a subtle but present way.

    • bridgeanneartandwriting February 20, 2015 at 1:43 pm Reply

      Thanks so much for that – I’m going to correct it straight away. I will look out for RJ Anderson’s books too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: